The song is “Elizabeth,” recorded by The Statler Brothers in 1983 and written by Jimmy Fortune, the group’s new tenor. It was the first song Jimmy Fortune ever wrote, and it went all the way to No. 1. Its name came from an old movie, a stranger in Tulsa, and one of Hollywood’s most famous women.

The Fill-In Who Stayed

Jimmy Fortune, a singer from Nelson County, Virginia, was performing at a local ski resort when Lew DeWitt, the original tenor of The Statler Brothers, heard him sing. Lew DeWitt was battling Crohn’s disease, and when he needed surgery around Christmas, he recommended Jimmy Fortune as his temporary replacement.

Lew DeWitt was never able to return to the stage, and in August 1982 Jimmy Fortune became a permanent member, singing alongside Harold Reid, Don Reid, and Phil Balsley.

“Only If It’s Good Enough”

Jimmy Fortune had never written a song. He asked Harold Reid and Don Reid whether the group would record one if he wrote it. Their answer: yes, if it was good enough.

In 1983, on the tour bus heading to Tulsa, Oklahoma, Harold Reid and Don Reid put on the 1956 film Giant, starring Elizabeth Taylor, Rock Hudson, and James Dean. Part of it had been filmed in Virginia, so they thought their new tenor should see it. Jimmy Fortune had never seen it. He later said he fell in love with Elizabeth Taylor on screen.

A Name in the Crowd

That night in Tulsa, after the show, a woman in the crowd walked up to Jimmy Fortune, held out her hand, and introduced herself: Elizabeth. He took it as a sign that somebody was trying to tell him something.

He wrote the song right away and played it for Harold Reid and Don Reid the next day. They kept their word. “Elizabeth” went onto the first Statler Brothers record with Jimmy Fortune in the lineup.

“It was the first song I ever wrote.” — Jimmy Fortune

What the Song Says

“Elizabeth” is a simple, aching love song. The singer remembers sharing a life with a woman who gave him strength and made everything feel new. He longs to see her face and be held again, unsure he can live without her. The whole song is built around one name, the name a stranger offered in Tulsa.

From First Song to No. 1

On March 17, 1984, “Elizabeth” reached No. 1 on Billboard’s country singles chart. It was the first Statler Brothers hit to feature Jimmy Fortune on lead vocals, and it earned him Songwriter of the Year honors at the Music City News awards.

The Day the Movie Star Came Aboard

A few years later, Elizabeth Taylor was filming a TV movie in Arizona when she learned The Statler Brothers were nearby. She had heard the song, and she called their management to ask if they could meet.

The group went to the film set, and Elizabeth Taylor stepped onto their tour bus. Because it was close to her birthday, they sang “Happy Birthday” first. Then Harold Reid, the group’s bass singer, stood up and told her they had written “Elizabeth” just for her.

“We wrote ‘Elizabeth’ just for you.” — Harold Reid, as recalled by Jimmy Fortune

Jimmy Fortune had not written it for her. But he sat across the table and sang it to her anyway, and he later admitted the group itself started the story that the song was about Elizabeth Taylor. He remembered her as kind and humble, with beautiful blue eyes, and called it one of the highlights of his career.

Why It Still Matters

About 25 years after The Statler Brothers took it to the top, the bluegrass duo Dailey & Vincent recorded “Elizabeth” for a tribute album and earned a Grammy nomination for it.

But its story belongs to Jimmy Fortune: a tenor who filled a sick friend’s place, a movie on a bus ride, and a stranger who said her name at exactly the right moment. Sometimes the best songs are not planned. They are noticed.