“THE DANCE” WAS REJECTED BY EVERY ARTIST IN NASHVILLE FOR 3 YEARS — THEN IT BECAME THE SONG GARTH BROOKS CALLS HIS FAVORITE OF ALL TIME. In 1986, Tony Arata had just moved to Nashville. “The Dance” was only the second song he ever wrote there. He played it at the Bluebird Café, at Douglas Corner — anywhere that would let him on stage. For 3 years, every artist and label in town turned it down. Then one night, a young guy from Oklahoma nobody knew sat in the audience. He couldn’t understand the words to the first two songs. But when “The Dance” started, he leaned forward — and before Arata finished, Garth Brooks walked up and said: “If I ever get a record deal, I’m doing that song.” Here’s the thing nobody talks about. When Brooks finally recorded it, the version sounded so different that Arata listened to the whole album and thought his song didn’t make the cut. He didn’t even recognize it. That song went No. 1 in 1990. Won ACM Song of the Year. Got a Grammy nomination. The album it lived on sold over 10 million copies. Brooks still calls it his favorite song he’s ever recorded.
The Song Nashville Rejected for 3 Years and the Moment Garth Brooks Changed Everything In 1986, Tony Arata had just…